Before rising to viral fame with a series of quirky videos spoofing Hollywood actors, Michigan native Rob Cantor sang, played guitar, and wore a yellow necktie for brainy Ann Arbor-based indie pop quintet Tally Hall.

The band (each member of which was distinguished by a different colored tie) formed in 2002 and quickly became known for their sharp wit, strong musicianship, and penchant for whimsical and comedic elements.