The Smiths vs Morrissey vs Johnny Marr (rated by Total Tracks Played)

The Smiths' Acrimonious Split

The Smiths disbanded in 1987 at their creative peak, following escalating tensions between Morrissey and Johnny Marr over the band's musical direction and Morrissey's increasing control. The final straw came when Marr felt creatively stifled and exhausted by the band's intense work schedule and Morrissey's domineering personality. Unlike many breakups, this one was swift and final - Marr simply quit, effectively ending the band instantly.

The Bitter End:

The split was particularly acrimonious, with Morrissey and Marr barely speaking afterward. Legal battles over royalties and the band's legacy continued for years. The other members - Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce - found themselves caught in the middle of the creative partnership's collapse.

Solo Careers:

Morrissey launched a successful solo career that continued his provocative, literary approach to lyrics while exploring different musical styles. His solo hits included "Suedehead," "The Last of the Famous International Playboys," and "Everyday Is Like Sunday." His solo work allowed him complete creative control and the ability to pursue his increasingly controversial political and social commentary without having to compromise with bandmates. However, his career has been marked by periods of commercial decline and public controversies.

Johnny Marr became one of indie rock's most sought-after guitarists, joining The The, Electronic (with New Order's Bernard Sumner), Modest Mouse, and The Cribs before launching his own solo career in 2013. His post-Smiths work showcased his versatility beyond jangly guitar pop, exploring electronic music, alternative rock, and more experimental sounds. His solo albums revealed his songwriting abilities independent of Morrissey's lyrics.

The Unfulfilled Legacy:

Unlike many disbanded groups, The Smiths have never reunited, with both Morrissey and Marr firmly ruling out any reconciliation. This has only added to their mystique and the "what if" speculation among fans.

The breakup freed Morrissey to fully embrace his role as indie rock's most divisive figure while allowing Marr to demonstrate his musical range beyond the band's signature sound, though neither quite recaptured the magic of their collaboration.

Genre breakdown

9.9bn all-time streams (20 May '26)

9.6bn all-time streams (9 May '26)

5.6bn all-time streams (17 May '26)